
I’m going to go out on a limb and say that unless you’ve been living under a rock, you probably know about PSY’s “Gangnam Style”. I’m also going to take a wild guess and assume that, by reading this on Soshified, you’re probably a Girls’ Generation fan. Within the past year, SONEs celebrated the girls’ debut in the United States and swelled with pride after their appearances on “Late Show with David Letterman” and “Live! With Kelly”, but the progress into the Western market has not advanced since those landmark events nearly eight months ago.
At the time, we viewed Girls’ Generation’s appearances on American television as a huge step forward in K-Pop’s seemingly inevitable advancement into Western markets. They remain historic, but they seem like tiny droplets in an ocean compared to the tidal wave of explosive popularity that PSY has experienced with “Gangnam Style”. At this rate, one would think that the sky is falling for Girls’ Generation’s chances of long-term success in the West, right? Despite the fact that PSY’s music doesn’t exactly fall into the traditional K-Pop musical mold of catchy repetitive hooks and stunning good looks, he managed to captivate America and the entire world in a matter of weeks. The recent “New Yorker” article featuring Girls’ Generation even suggested that PSY “may have subverted K-pop’s chances of making it big in the West.”
With all of these things in mind, I still think that Girls’ Generation’s chances of success in the Western market are as good as they have ever been and that they could even be better after the unexpected popularity of “Gangnam Style”. I’ve heard most of the opinions arguing that “Gangnam Style” is bad for K-Pop’s popularity in the West, and I know that many people are uneasy about its success. I’ve heard the concerns about Westerners only caring about the silly dance or that the stereotypical portrayal of Asians is bad for K-Pop. The counter-argument I have in mind for those concerns is that I see the “Gangnam Style” phenomenon as an opportunity to insert Korea and its culture into the general consciousness of the Western population.

For a large number of people in the West, Korea is still somewhat of a mystery. The history of the Korean War and the division of the North and the South are well-known, and the popularity of Korean electronics and cars has been on the rise. Despite that, Korean culture and entertainment are, to a significant degree, an unknown entity to the rest of the world. Most Westerners don’t even know that something such as K-Pop or Girls’ Generation exists. We take it for granted because, as SONEs and K-Pop fans, we are exposed to Korean culture and entertainment on a regular basis, so we are aware of what Korea has to offer. Now, the general population in the West also knows about a small piece of Korea’s rich culture, but there is so much room for expansion.
PSY has made it a point to let people know that he is from Korea, even going so far as to say “대한민국만세” (loosely translated as “Korea rules”) live on the “Today” show. K-Pop fans may think that the image of Korea and K-Pop being portrayed by “Gangnam Style” is misguided, but among Western audiences that image is overwhelmingly positive at the moment. PSY is a well-educated and independent-minded artist whom I believe can be a good ambassador for Korea and its culture. It’s easier for him to connect to American audiences because he attended an American university for four years, he can speak relatively fluent English, and he has an easygoing personality. These types of useful traits also apply to Girls’ Generation’s English-speaking members. If PSY is able to help build the image of Korea in a positive manner within the minds of people in the West, I only see it as a beneficial situation for Girls’ Generation. They will be able to make similar connections with English-speaking audiences because of Jessica, Tiffany, and the other members who have surely been practicing their English skills.
Think of the cultural-awakening experiences that many of us have had as Girls’ Generation fans. Many of us started out by watching a few Girls’ Generation music videos and/or SoShi Subs videos, and then from there, everything began to snowball. Soon enough, we fell in love with everything Korean. We ended up wanting to try more Korean food. We started to learn more about Korean culture. Some of us even started on the difficult path of trying to learn the Korean language. Many of us developed a beautiful image of Korea, Korean products, and Korean culture in our minds because of Girls’ Generation. Some of us even took an adventurous leap by travelling around the world to visit Korea. I think the potential is there for this same effect to take place in the West, but in reverse: as Korea’s reputation grows and becomes increasingly positive and popular, the effect of Girls’ Generation proudly proclaiming “We are from Korea” will begin to carry more weight and draw more attention. If Girls’ Generation’s oft-rumored English album eventually gets made and released and it turns out to be a rousing success, that will only reinforce the notion that Korea’s culture and entertainment deserve the attention and praise that we’ve been giving it for years.

I’m not without my concerns in all of this. I hope that Girls’ Generation doesn’t Americanize their own style to fit the Western audience, and I want them to be able to say, “Yes, we are a Korean pop girl group, and this is our distinctive style.” With new Japanese and Korean singles and albums around the corner, it’s unclear when the next step in their attempt to conquer the United States will occur. I, for one, hope that whenever Girls’ Generation takes that next step, they will benefit from the brighter spotlight on Korean culture and entertainment that I think PSY can create, and I’m confident that the girls themselves will also contribute to and benefit from Korea’s cultural expansion.
Disclaimer: Views expressed are solely those of the author and are not representative of the Soshified community as a whole.
Written by: cucumberoni@soshified
Edited by: residentbenchwarmer@soshified, taengsoshi@soshified, bhost909@soshified, Akino_Makoto@soshified, MoonSoshi9@soshified
Have a news item that you think Soshified should know about? Leave us a tip or e-mail us at [email protected].
Follow us on Twitter: http://twitter.com/soshified for the latest on Girls’ Generation.
great article, as i may agree with 99% of what this article is about, i do believe that PSY’s case is different ! it did open the door for westerners to take interest in Korea but sticking to only Kpop may not get SNSD there as fast as we hope, they may have to sacrifice a little bit of what SNSD is all about to make it there ..
take WG for an example, they’re climbing the ladder step by step .. but in order to do so they lost their #1 spot as the best korean girl group, some took time off from school, and some members dropped out. it takes more than amazing skills and fluent language to make it in there .. PSY for example need to release English tracks soon if he wishes for his popularity in the states to last, cause sooner or later the American market want you to Americanize your style to fit their mainstream just like how they did to THE WANTED, an Irish-British ballad group had to come up with a clubby fast tempo-ed song to get attention there ..
SNSD are great, but like Sooyoung said in the LOOK fanmeet, they are gradually NOT getting attention for their English album .. another US release would be a risk of time, money, and effort ..
my opinion is that they should do more concerts and fan meetings in America, get the public to ask for more, than release a US single without promoting .. to see the feedback and the orders for them to appear on the US TV, then they should make a leap of releasing an all English US album ..
again, great article .. i really enjoyed reading :) thanks
I agree with you, it’ll be risky going full on with an album but having fanmeets and more concerts will bring out the kpop fans more and more. Getting publicity from flash mobs and such will help spread more kpop everywhere.
Psy’s success is the bridge the K-scene needs to break into, not only American market, but global success. Most people take it for granted what they see in Korean music because of its very accessibility to them. Do people actually know to what extent does the general WORLD take Gangnam Style? just going into a random street and you can have someone sing (or dance) along to Gangnam Style. I want to mention Justin Bieber because he is about the ‘it’ artist in money-making, famous (be it hated or loved) but he never achieved a worldwide success like Psy has done, the way it becomes ~everyone’s~ song. When was the last time a song like that came out?
Friday? oh boy. Not even close.
People are also forgetting how we fans were first exposed to SNSD (or Kpop). A mere chance? or a random related search? a word of mouth? Gangnam Style will be their story.
As for their music being more ‘Americanized’, there will be that high possibility, but not in the way it will sound so much American they will be barely recognisable. My memory has failed me but I do remember a mention (by news/SM staff… uh TV people) about SNSD’s success being with a flavour of their own, SM is smart enough to know that changing sound completely will not only kill their chances in US (probably branded as wannabes) but of those who are already fans of the girls who will be less than interested in their future music.
I found John Seabrook’s article pretty detailed and interesting. In fact he identified a number of obstacles to the success of K-pop and SNSD in the US. His mention of PSY was only one possible obstacle. For a more in-depth look at PSY’s US hit and implications, read this August 28 article from the Wall Street Journal Arts and Entertainment blog: http://blogs.wsj.com/speakeasy/2012/08/28/gangnam-style-viral-popularity-in-u-s-has-koreans-puzzled-gratified/
As a relatively new convert to K-pop and SNSD, and one who is probably older than the average Shoshified member, I’m afraid to say that I have serious doubts about the ability of SNSD to achieve “success” in the US market, that is, if your measure of success is a top 10 or top 25 ranking on the Billboard Hot-100 or I-Tunes lists. I believe there is a market for K-pop and SNSD in this country. In fact, I wish Interscope would make the whole back catalog of SNSD easily available in the US. Aside from the xenophobia issue and their 60’s retro style, what Seabrook failed to mention is the enormous diversity of the US music market. There are so many genres and no single genre dominates. To achieve that top 25 success requires that the group appeal across genres, and I just don’t see that happening.
So, don’t misunderstand me, I am a K-pop fan, and love SNSD (especially TaeTisSeo, sure hope there is more of that coming) but, my best hope is that the K-pop music become more accessible in the US.
The Boys was actually not a good enough song to have America hear. They should have gone with one of the better ones from that album. It’s sad to think that only two songs on the album got music videos and promotion when there are better songs on it. And that the Japanese album has many singles for one album.
Someone said Taeyeon doesn’t like the song The Boys anyways? Does anyone know where to find that? I don’t blame her. It’s not all that catchy. I don’t listen to it if I can help it. I prefer their other songs by far. I don’t mean to put down the girls. They sang great. It wasn’t their fault the song is terrible. Would have been nice if the English lyrics matched the Korean ones at all. I hope their English album has the Korean style their past songs have had. I like them better from a couple years ago than how they are now. Still love them anyways!! <3
I just heard it on Sukira Radio I don’t remember the exact episode unfortunately.. Great comment btw I agree completely. Also thought that the album had much better songs.
I wouldn’t be a fan of SNSD today if I hadn’t seen PSY’s Gangnam Style on youtube. It made me want to watch music videos from other groups and when I saw SNSD’s Paparazzi and Gee I immediately fell in love. I wanted to know there names, who they were, everything. And I know I’m not the only one like that. There is no such thing as bad press.
“Gangnam style” is just another passing fad. Once PSY has appeared on all the relevant TV shows and the important celebrities have been seen doing “the dance” it will all fade away. The the big appeal for westerners is that it is currently trending and they feel left out if they are not a part if it. Unfortunately any K-Pop group that tries to break in to the western market while this is still on peoples radar will undoubtably be compared to it. I hope SM realizes this and doesn’t do anything to jeopardize our girls chances of a successful break through.
to be honest, I like PSY’s songs..like Champion, right now..etc
but how many of the 500mil views on YT..know what the song means, other than the words “Oppa Gangnam Style” and the horse dance..
If the horse dance was removed, would the song have gotten so much interest..
PSY once said..he feared that ppl start to sterotype “koreans” as ppl who do the horse dance.. and when Korean singers introduce themselves as they are from korea, ppl will immediately ask them to show them the “horse dance”..
Just like what those rude ppl did to Tiger JK.. and did not consider his feelings as an artiste.. and just asking him to “entertain” the crowd by doing the horse dance.. which is why he “blew up” .
i find it irritating when i see other singers all agreeing to parody the dance when they are asked to… its just like asking a dog to “roll over and play dead when i shout ‘bang’ ” or “raise your paw when i say so”
some one should tell the host.. i’m sorry but thats not my style of music or thats not what my song is about..
Can you find and link something about Tiger JK, I’d like to see it please. I agree with you btw.
There is an article about it below..
http://www.soompi.com/2012/09/25/tiger-jk-goes-on-racist-rant-due-to-gangnam-style-heckling-at-the-creators-project/
“I hope that Girls’ Generation doesn’t Americanize their own style to fit the Western audience”… I hope so too but from what happened with “The Boys” it seems that they are trying to make it fit the Western audience. They made a whole bunch of remixes and even included Snoop Dogg in an attempt to make it popular but that didn’t work obviously. I became a sone because of their Korean songs and their original styles/personalities. It would be terrible to see them turn into “sellouts” and putting on an act just to try to be popular. Actually, I wonder sometimes if they personally want to become popular in America. Especially because I read that Taeyeon doesn’t even like “The Boys” and I’m sure other at least one other member dislikes it too. If SNSD does want to become popular in America, I doubt they want it in a way that includes Snoop Dogg remixes, awkward English lyrics, and americanizing. In the end, I really want whatever it is that they truly want. It may be unrealistic as SM obviously makes some decisions for the girls… but I wish that all of the members happy could be happy with their songs/performances and not overworked..
Since I live in NY, I was able to go to every event early this year and in 2011. It was truly amazing and my first time seeing them, but I didn’t even like “The Boys” (the song) and felt somewhat embarrassed/uncomfortable watching them sing it on an English program. Also, all of the girls were INSANELY tired and overworked at this time. As I said, I loved meeting SNSD, but not under those conditions because I actually felt somewhat guilty.
You could say I am looking into it way too much, but it’s because I feel connected to all of the members and care about them. It is for these reasons that I am not a huge “Global Generation” activist.
Anyway, this is all just my opinion of course and if SNSD as a whole DOES want to be popular in the US, then I will support that. Probably will tend to keep listening to the Korean (and Japanese) songs though because the main reason that I’m here in the first place is that I dislike English music and don’t listen to any.
I dun like the fact that SM is getting more and more western composers/choreographers, to compose the songs or dance moves for their groups.. I am tired of hearing… Oh the dance or song is designed/written.. by the famous XYZ composer who also did who and who’s dance/song..etc.
I wonder what happen to all the beautiful songs by the korean composers.. the ppl who gave us the great hits of 2009, 2010..and earlier..
I am happy GG going on USA TV and such, but if it means force the girls to memorize how to sing in another language besides Korea/Japanese.. i think its sad..
Rather than trying to change k-pop into something, westerners love.. i think its better to keep to using korean composers/choreographers.. and let the world know…this is how kpop is like.. either you like it or you dont.
Agreed 100%.
I agree…
I just wanna say that Girls’ Generation will definitely make a huge impact in the United States next year and i’m super duper confident on that. I know that Girls’ Generation is scheduled to make an American debut next year and I also know that everyone in the United States will love this girl group and continue on loving the girls for many years to come. I don’t have any worries or concerns about what concept the girls will do for their English album next year but all that I really can say is Girls’ Generation will absolutely make a pretty amazing first impression on the Americans. I stand by my words
To be honest, I am upset about this whole situation starting with Girls’ Generation’s “American debut”
First off, I think SM felt forced to release a song 100% in English, so they just put together a bunch of different melodies and nonsense words from the English language to create a song. Then, instead of taking the effort to create an album fully in English (like Boa’s debut), they just release the exact same CD from Korea in America (supposedly. I went to every store I could find and I looked for the album, but it was never there.). I think the album was very low-quality compared to the one in Korea that came with multiple goodies such as a mystery photo card, tin casing, and a poster. As for their own “American” album released on iTunes; seriosuly? Just 10 remixes of the same song? And they also only had 1 concert in America. One! And sure, they had a couple big interviews with famous Western (*clears throat*, New Yorker) companies and 2 TV performances, but that’s it!
As for Psy, I’m a bit upset that every K-Pop star worked very hard to make their American debuts successful only to be overshadowed by someone who releases 1 song and all of a sudden breaks a bunch of records. I do admit, I am one of those “western people” (as mentioned in the article) who think the song is only popular for the hilarity
of the music video and the hype of it being different and also the hilarity of the dance. I don’t think anyone finds any talent in it (like I do) therefore I think K-Pop isn’t going to become big all over the world because it’s hard for many people to recognize true talent and dedication.
*Please Note* I have nothing against Girls’ Generation, Psy, “The Boys”, “Gangnam Style”, SM Entertainment, YG Entertainment, New York, America (Westerners), or humanity. I am just aggravated about the whole situation where everything is combined.
I think you maybe missed the mark on “The Boys”. Yes, it was only one English song as opposed to a full English album, but that was likely SM learning from BoA’s debut. It charted, but didn’t really do anything other than that. I saw the lone English song on “The Boys” as an attempt to gauge the market before widespread release and promotion. If memory serves, the song itself did very well on iTunes and Amazon, and the album didn’t do too badly, either (for the record, I bought my copy at Best Buy the day of release, but I haven’t seen it there since). With the appearances on Letterman and Live! with Kelly, along with their concerts in the US, they’ve created awareness. I’m waiting for them to make an attempt to capitalize on it. Perhaps the popularity of Gangnam Style will help SM make that move.
S♥ne4Soshi: I don’t think Gangnam Style was really made to show off any talent so it’s normal if you can’t find any in it. Personally I am not a fan of that type of music and I’m tired of hearing about the song by now
I agree with this article…it’s spot on. PSY has changed the way K pop was previously. I’ve been into K pop since 2009 and I would have never thought in 3 and a half years that it would be this big. It’s not just with PSY, but with 2NE1 and BIGBANG as well. They are touring the USA selling out arenas already without any promo here. I find it so amazing and it makes me so happy!!!
Girls Generation performing earlier this year wasn’t a waste. I feel like they opened the doors for other K pop artists and they’ve gained some fans. I’m on Youtube all the time and read comments about people discovering Girls Generation for the first time. It makes me so proud to be a K pop fan. I really believe in our 9 angels! I hope that they release an English album sometime in the near future because I’m looking forward to it!!! Even the Wonder Girls who have been trying for the past 3 years to break into the American market may finally have a shot. Their current single “Like Money” is getting played on the radio and they’ve been doing promo for it. I even seen their music video on MTV which was so shocking! So, I truly believe that America is ready for something different. K pop music is amazing!!! Girls Generation should just stay true to themselves when releasing their English album. I want the girls to be treated fairly here and not become too Americanized which is my only conserns.
My thoughts exactly!
I think an English album with a few well chosen songs and a few TV appearances will have them well on the way to success.
An interesting idea is if they could do a promotional campaign in America with Hyundai, Samsung or LG that would really put them on primetime TV.
A really interesting point that I think paints a brighter picture than what others have been imagining so far. It’s also worth pointing out that Psy has benefited from the efforts of all those who came before him as well. The Wonder Girls, Girls’ Generation, and many other K-pop groups created the foundation and network that helped Gangnam Style spread as fast as it did. With these fans posting the links to the song absolutely everywhere, it brought attention to the song from all the right people. With any luck, Psy may do the same for other K-pop groups.
Girls Generation will hopefully get chances to go on tv shows like Ellen or a reappearence on Live with Kelly (and Michael) Hopefully people will first like them as a group and then becomes like us
SONEs and love each individual member
as we do!
~Hwaiting!!!
NIce article! I can’t wait for Soshi to do English album, well hopefully Interscope Records keep their faith in their young artist group. Soshi is going to set the world on fire (in a good way). More and more peeps are going to want to learn more about them and where they come from. I’m waiting patiently. I hope Interscope execs don’t lose the girls Asian flavor, keep it as close to themselves as possible. Soshi hwaiting!
I see some peeps already have negative feelings towards the girls English song Cheap Creeper, oh well not everyone can be please. The best thing is that Soshi are broadening their style and for most part it’s always a good thing to try other things and see how it goes. No matter what they’re still going to be representing S.K. to the fullest even if they’re singing in English. :)
Rather than basing my position on this issue solely on opinion, I will try and use some historical data to backup my point of view…does anyone remember the Macarena? Do you think Latin America found that a proper song to summarize their culture? Of course not! However, did this catchy song sort of force mainstream America to realize and begin to understand the Latin American influence on American culture? Yes! Did Latin American culture slowly become an essential part of the wide breadth of American experiences? Yes! That is exactly what I see occurring here. Psy has forced mainstream America to open their eyes to the rising Asian cultural influence in America, and they will slowly come to embrace the culture, just as they did for Latin America. This will absolutely benefit groups like SNSD as well as groups to come after them. I am extremely thankful to Psy for getting his foot in the door of the American consciousness. And for those hoping American culture will be open-minded enough to accept Korean culture, please stop acting in a contradictory nature and demanding that all Korean culture in America adapt in no way to the hosting culture. In conclusion, to state my position simply, thank you Psy! You have paved a hopefully road for Asian music and Asian culture in America!
Interesting point to ponder on. I was honestly surprised when I read the article title on the forums sidebar. Then, I thought, the article is rather timely and relevant. I had not been fond of Gangnam Style for quite some time. However, I can not deny its popularity (even to the point when my friends who aren’t K-pop fans texted me just asking about it) and its marketability. Regarding its impact to the West, PSY is an intellectual and his song is a sort of innovation in the music scene. I think it may help the expansion of K-pop, but to me it appears like a sort of a craze that’ll be forgotten sooner or later. I can not avoid the notion that it may be seen as a joke, since a lot of people already get annoyed by it and other people just want to join the bandwagon. In general, Gangnam Style may help the K-pop industry; however, I think the push that it will give K-pop in the West would be relatively minimal and not that significant.
Couldn’t agree more
I believe it’s not just PSY Gangnam style that is a contribute to Kpop. There were many other artists try making it into the west. Like Wonder Girls, BoA, and maybe a little of Girls’ Generation. Little by little, these artists pop out of no where on screen in TV. Of course, people will be aware of these Asians which is Kpop. These artists are steps to Kpop or Girls’ Generation’s success to global.
I couldn’t agree more with this article. Lately people were all bashing Psy for taking all K-charts, well it was kinda sad that TVXQ couldn’t win, but to think of it.. Psy actually deserves that. These days,it’s like,who in the world doesn’t know Gangnam Style? Even my teacher suddenly talked about it while teaching math. That was crazy.
I like how you think of this Gangnam Style craze this way, because actually I’ve also ever thought that Psy could make K-pop to break the US market easier. And I also hoped that Soshi will NEVER change their music style just to break the US market. I agree with this article a lot. Nice!
maybe yes maybe not..and i’m probably one of those kpop fans who think gangnam style as a western electro-pop song with korean lyrics..but the most important thing is SNSD should maintain their distinct image, so other people (non-sone/non-kpop fans) won’t think them as PCD with more members or 9 britneys in a group…as for language in the songs, as long as it has a real meaning (not some meanless song) and fit with the tune, i don’t see other non korean language as a sin to put in a kpop song. Kpop should be known as music genre, not known as bunch of pop songs with korean lyrics..
this is a very interesting insight on the issue and I have to say that i do agree with this article. not just SNSD, but i believe that all korean artists, be it actors, actresses, singers and even comedians would be able to benefit from this craze that Psy has brought about. We gotta hand it to the man, he has certainly contributed a whole lot to the whole Korean Wave movement and i believe that in the future, the K-pop scene would be able to make a bigger impact on the world as a whole, an impact bigger than at present.
maybe its just me, but i defo can’t wait to see what SNSD and Korea, as a whole, has to offer the world in terms of entertainment. :)
The fact that PSY sang his song in Korean, even in America, is the thing I like the most. Whenever I hear a Korean or Japanese song, and if there is an English version of it, I dislike the English version. It just feels wrong. Even the English version of “The Boys”.
I hope SNSD won’t release many more songs in English. They shouldn’t conform themselves just for the English speaking audience. If America doesn’t accept their unique Korean style, it’s their own fault.
Ikr’? I also hate the English version of the boy too. I love the way they were before :( They didn’t care much about breaking into the US and happy with what they were doing. I mean they’re happy now too but weren’t they happier a few years ago? I’m one of those sones who want the girls to keep their distinct images…
Nice article … I think sones should really read this and for me its an eye opener. It gives us the opportunity to view the Gangnam Style craze in a different direction….Thank you for this article
hmm agree much.
I hope the rumor which said soshi is going to make an English album will not just be a rumor.
it’ll be great if they really make it and it becomes a huge hit. it’ll certainly be a gold gate for girls’ generation to be a successful worldwide artist