Jump to content


Photo

[COMP] Let's ReviewA collection of reviews from a sone just like you


  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
3 replies to this topic
Vapour Vapour
  • Donors
  • 300 posts
#1

Posted 08 September 2014 - 03:50 AM

Let's Review

 

Welcome to Da Funk's review thread where I hope to provide you, the reader, with some insight into the various merchandise of Girls' Generation and maybe even influence a purchase of yours.

 

Now, I'm no trained musician so the reviews won't contain some deep and profound messages (if I can help it) but more the thoughts of a common or garden sone.

 

I do hope that you find my reviews helpful and, with a bit of luck and maybe some money, entertaining to read.

 

About

 

Each review will start with a quick summary of the merchandise in question, so that those who don't wish to read an in-depth look can still get a feel for the item.

 

Please remember that all opinions are, of course, my own but I encourage people to reply with their own thoughts and opinions.

 

Thank you for the time you take to read my reviews.

 

Helpful hints

 

Whilst "Concept" has a score in the summary, it is only briefly touched upon when discussing the packaging due to the amount of personal preference attached to it.

 

Overall ratings are judged as such:

0-30% = Poor

31-50% = Lacklustre

51-60% = Average

61-70% = Good

71-90% = Fantastic

91-100% = Outstanding

 

Reviews

 

Completed

Spoiler

 

In Progress

Spoiler

 

Planned

Spoiler


Edited by Da Funk, 10 September 2014 - 08:32 AM.

  • 1

Fanfics (Currently on hiatus): How Hard Can It Be? | Role Reversal | SNSD Revelations - The Cover-up
Review Thread: Let's Review


Vapour Vapour
  • Donors
  • 300 posts
#2

Posted 10 September 2014 - 08:17 AM

Let's Review - Episode 1 - Make a wish

 

Album title: 소원을 말해봐 (Genie) (otherwise known as Tell Me Your Wish)

No. of tracks: 6

Album length: ~22 minutes

Packaging: 7/10

Concept: 5/5

Songs: 7/10

Overall: 19/25 - 76% satisfaction rating

Comments: My personal favourite concept, backed up with some good songs but not outstanding packaging.

 

Clicky clicky the button to read the full review below

Spoiler

 

Thank you for reading, comments are most appreciated!


  • 2

Fanfics (Currently on hiatus): How Hard Can It Be? | Role Reversal | SNSD Revelations - The Cover-up
Review Thread: Let's Review


katiecSNSD katiecSNSD
  • Donors
  • 283 posts
#3

Posted 10 September 2014 - 12:40 PM

I love how thorough your reviews are. They remind me of mine, since I like to add as many details as possible. :) I agree with pretty much everything you have to say about the songs. I, too, would give Genie and My Child the highest ratings, and Boyfriend is probably my least favorite on the album.

 

Looking forward to reading your other reviews!


  • 0

foreverwithyou.jpg


GGFanJan GGFanJan
  • Donors
  • 710 posts
#4

Posted 24 September 2014 - 07:48 AM

Your review is on point and I mostly share your opinion about the songs. Boyfriend is one of the weakest songs they ever released, in my opinion. My Child is such a great song, one of my faves too. 

 

I'll be looking forward to your other reviews, keep it up. :)


  • 0

Don't hide youself inside of an always strong appearance. 

Sometimes, it's okay to show your hidden vulnerable expression.

 

 



0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users