24 replies to this topic

[LovelyxBeauty]

Not a suggestion or a question, but I just wanted to say this is a great idea!  with CDs being quite expensive (especially the Japanese releases) and the girls having quite a lot of merchandise, it'll be great to read reviews of others before people decide to part with their money  Along with this being on the forum rather than the portal, you can also have people add onto your opinions so people can make an informative decision .  I may review some stuff of my own seeing as I got a new camera.

[A(mber)]

First of all; Great idea!

Secondly; If I want to make a thread with all my reviews, would they have to be limited to one tag? Like, would I just have to do an Album review thread and then make a different thread for MV reviews? Or can I put them all in 1 thread with the Comp tag?

[takenine]

For general cases, I would always refer to the rules/About Sections pages as your overarching rule of thumb:

[COMP] for compilations about anything

- Use compilations if you want to review several things under one common category.

In a specific case of Album and MV, I personally would say they're "common" enough to review the album along with its appropriate MV/PV together.

[A(mber)]

In a specific case of Album and MV, I personally would say they're "common" enough to review the album along with its appropriate MV/PV together.

Thanks! I wasn't sure which one to do because I want to make a review thread and use the fanfic-update-system-thingy for my reviews^-^

[SodaStereo]

Can anyone review The Best?
I'm seriously considering buying one that says it's limited and has a bonus DVD but I heard there are other versions and I really want to make sure I'm making the right choice. As the other SONE mention, their stuff, though high in quality, it's very expensive.