Jump to content


Photo

[COMP] Heart & Soul ReviewsJoin me in my quest as I review various GG works from a musician's perspective.


  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
8 replies to this topic
Heart_Soul Heart_Soul
  • ♬Radio DJ
  • 61 posts
#1

Posted 11 March 2014 - 09:48 AM

Hey Soshified! This is my first time attempting to write any sort of cohesive review for music. I figured it might be helpful for some people to read reviews from a musician and composer's perspective, so they're here if you need them! Feel free to discuss or ask anything related to the songs or reviews, there are no silly questions or opinions here. Just make sure you're following the forum rules!

 

What I will try to do in my reviews is mainly break down each song in it's style, structure, and instrumentation with my added opinion as an artist. I'll do my best to make any musical concepts easy to understand. I can't promise each review will be 100% consistent, but I'll definitely try my best to elaborate my key ideas. My main objective is to help offer information or a different view that you might be seeking. :)

 

 

As of right now, I'll be reviewing Girls' Generation's Mr. Mr. mini album. I finished the first three tracks, expect the rest of them soon!

 

 

 

Girls' Generation - Mr. Mr. (Mini Album)

 

Mr. Mr.

 

I’ve heard a lot people say weren’t sure how they felt about “Mr. Mr.” when they first heard it in its entirety. I would say I leaned more towards the “it’s at least good” side of the spectrum. For me, it started off like “Okay, this is pretty cool. It reminds me a lot of ‘Flower Power’. I wonder what the chorus will be like.” And when the chorus did come in, I was pleasantly surprised. It felt like a breath of fresh air. For me, the verses were a little lackluster; they were strong, but they didn’t feel as solid musically as the choruses. The change from the verse to the pre-chorus where Sunny first comes in also doesn’t feel very smooth. It felt just a tiny bit forced. However, the build-up was solid and thankfully the choruses saved it for me, as well as the breakdown. Even though we already knew what it would sound like based on the teaser, the breakdown was still just as awesome. Not only to hear, but to watch GG show us their killer synchronization and choreography. Once the song moves into the final chorus is when things really start to get good though. After the first part, the chorus modulates up into another key and the girls flawlessly move with it. But wait, there’s more! It modulates a second time into an even higher key and still sounds spot-on. While it modulates, SNSD is belting out their multiple vocal flourishes which really helps bring things home.

 

Because this is the title track that Girl’s Generation is promoting, I expected there wasn’t going to be much complicated vocal stuff going on in the melody; and I was right. It’s a solid, yet simple and catchy pop melody that the mass public can easily follow. It’s something almost essential for success. However, despite the need for a simple melody, our girls still brought the fire and burned down some of the wall around the “pop-zone” with their vocal skills in the last chorus. I also have to mention the lyrics and their concept. After hearing the song with a translation, I would say I quite enjoyed the lyrics. I’ve heard a lot of native-speaking Koreans think that some of the lines are awkward and cringe-worthy. I’m positive it’s from me being a native English speaker, but they totally sound fine translated. I really liked the idea and the positivity of trying to push this “Mr.” to be stronger and more confident. I’m particularly fond of the line “You make broken glass from scars turn into stars”; it just seems very cool and poetic to me. Overall, this is a concept you rarely find in American pop music, so I welcome it with open arms no matter how many times GG does it. Aside from certain pieces of the song structure, the vocals were great, and the instrumentation was solid as always.

 

I give “Mr. Mr.” a 8 pink stethoscopes out of 10.

 

 

Goodbye

 

I immediately knew I would like this track as soon as Tiffany broke in with her fantastic lower-range, supported by a fat and funky Rhodes piano. “Goodbye” begins with a very bluesy and funky sound that has a reminiscent feel of a song from TTS’s Twinkle album. I find the overall feel really smooth in this track as it goes from that very bluesy sound in the verses to powerful, poppy choruses. The instrument choices and entrances seem spot on from the guitars to drum kit. As the final chorus comes around there is a shaker, tambourine, and all kinds of rhythmic elements going on with the guitars that really helps push out that fantastic feeling a final chorus should have. I would say my favorite parts of Goodbye are the vocals and melody in the choruses; they caught my ear the most.

 

The vocals that really stood out to me in this track were between Tiffany, Taeyeon, Seohyun, Hyoyeon, and Yuri. Vocally, this was a pretty interesting track considering that Taeyeon and Jessica each got a chorus to themselves with harmonies from the rest of the girls. Even though it does sound good overall, I can hear the finesse of TTS’s vocals in this style of music transferring over from Twinkle. Not only TTS, but Hyoyeon and Yuri’s vocals also seem to have that spark for this kind of music. It’s a very sought-after vocal huskiness in blues and the like.

 

The only real gripe I have with this track is the end fadeout. I can think of at least 3 or 4 different ways they could have ended this track and had it sound ten times better than a fadeout. It doesn’t make it sound any worse, but I feel its missed chance for some good “oomph” in the last cadence. Other than that, it’s a fantastic track.

 

I give “Goodbye” 8.5 delicious Hyoyeon vocal parts out of 10.

 

 

Europa

 

Ever since Girls' Generation's debut, I've become very familiar with the work of Kenzie. I would go as far as saying I've become a sucker for her work, probably because it reminds me of my own style. I've thoroughly enjoyed just about every track she has written and composed for GG, and "Europa" was no different. As soon as I heard it, I knew for sure this was her song. (If you’re not too familiar with Kenzie, she is the producer that gave GG songs like “Into the New World”, “Himnae”, and “Oh!” among many other songs.)

From what I've read and heard, many people compare "Europa" to tracks from previous albums such as "Telepathy", "Vitamin", and "Express 999"... and they should! All of these tracks were done by the very same Kenzie.

 

I’m actually still not sure which track from Mr. Mr. is my favorite, but Europa is definitely among the top two. I really, really like many of the difference pieces to this song. The use of 7th chords in the progression really adds that extra “flavor” to it that you probably won’t find in many other pop songs. Not only that, but some really cool key changes during select parts of the chorus and the bridge makes me want to give the chord progressions an A+. Drums and percussion were also very well done. I think they were programmed to perform their role perfectly throughout each section of the song. They were slower and laid-back when they needed to be, upbeat when the song was pushing into the chorus, and they fit well with a lot of fills and other rhythmic cues from the rest of the instruments. Many times I hear very basic and repetitive beats with a lot of pop songs, (which isn’t necessarily a bad thing) and it definitely gets old after a while. The guitar was also really cool in this track. I know Kenzie likes to use a lot of funk-pop style guitar riffs in her songs (even if they can be REALLY quiet), much like you may hear in a Daft Punk song or various other styles of J-pop. Particularly, the small outro solo at the end was a nice touch. If only they could have ended “Goodbye” just as well :P

 

My favorite part of “Europa” though would have to be—you guessed it; the vocals. The melody, harmonies, and vocal flourishes in this song are all fantastic. Not for a single moment was I not totally entranced in GG’s vocals all throughout the song. Especially during the last chorus, I was already getting shivers at all the solo notes. Sunny’s note at 3:00 was epic, probably my favorite. There’s definitely a certain kind of magic that happens when you add some delay and reverb to an already fantastic singer’s voice. I should also mention the lyrics for this track. They were surprisingly dark to a certain extent, but in a very elegant and heartfelt way. To write an entire song in the perspective of Jupiter’s moon Europa in an allegory of love is pretty cool; interesting, at the very least. I give yet another kudos to Kenzie.

 

The only reason I’m not giving this a perfect score is because I’m waiting for the day SNSD really, REALLY knocks muh socks off.

I give “Europa” 9.5 barely audible guitar tracks out of 10.


  • 4

blazeaire blazeaire
  • Soshified
  • PipPip
  • 115 posts
#2

Posted 12 March 2014 - 03:27 AM

Yay I really like your in depth reviews, looking foward to reading the rest of it :) I agree, Goodbye sounded like something off the Twinkle album but that's probably why I like it since that album was awesome :D btw nice persona dp :P
  • 0

Heart_Soul Heart_Soul
  • ♬Radio DJ
  • 61 posts
#3

Posted 12 March 2014 - 12:53 PM

I'm glad you liked them, thanks for reading! I should have more up by this weekend.


  • 0

hyunieeee hyunieeee
  • Soshified
  • PipPipPip
  • 615 posts
#4

Posted 18 March 2014 - 04:37 AM

I agree with most of what you said. Especially when you said the Mr. Mr gets better during the last chorus, I particularly like the whole breakdown until the end. As for Goodbye, everything about that song just makes me want to listen to it every time and every listen just makes the song better. I'm curious as to what you think about the other tracks. Thanks again for this awesome review :) 


  • 0

wsFL5.png

------------------今タイムマシーン


Soxboii Soxboii
  • Soshified
  • Pip
  • 55 posts
#5

Posted 30 March 2014 - 01:15 PM

I really like your reviews. It is refreshing to see another more musically oriented review of pop music.

You are well-spoken and eloquent, expressing your views clearly and concisely.

You also obviously have a very good knowledge of what you're talking about, and I like the artistic opinions you include.

Please write more of them, I will never cease to enjoy your reviews.


  • 0

ZE3jOAb.jpg

 

"My specialty is sleeping, and my hobby is also sleeping”

-- Jessica


Heart_Soul Heart_Soul
  • ♬Radio DJ
  • 61 posts
#6

Posted 04 April 2014 - 02:26 PM

I really like your reviews. It is refreshing to see another more musically oriented review of pop music.

You are well-spoken and eloquent, expressing your views clearly and concisely.

You also obviously have a very good knowledge of what you're talking about, and I like the artistic opinions you include.

Please write more of them, I will never cease to enjoy your reviews.

 

Thanks so much! It really means a lot to me, I'm glad you enjoy them.

 

Sorry for taking so long for this update. Finals are coming up and school has been getting hectic, so I haven't had too much time to write. I updated the first post with my review of "Europa", hope it's helpful :)


  • 0

Soxboii Soxboii
  • Soshified
  • Pip
  • 55 posts
#7

Posted 07 April 2014 - 12:26 PM

No problem! I can understand the time crunch; school is preparing for the sprint to the finish. I'm really not looking forward to my finals this year.

 

I have to agree with you on Europa, and on most of Kenzie's songs. They're consistently some of my favorite songs on whatever album they release. I hope she keeps writing more and more for them. 


  • 0

ZE3jOAb.jpg

 

"My specialty is sleeping, and my hobby is also sleeping”

-- Jessica


Morozhen Morozhen
  • Soshified
  • PipPipPip
  • 582 posts
#8

Posted 07 May 2014 - 10:17 AM

It's nice to read a review from someone who's musically adept — I'm guessing you're a music major? It's nice how you analyzed the songs thoroughly in your review, not solely relying on preferences.

 

Contrary to most people, I really liked Europa even though I can't seem to put my love for it to words; now that you've mentioned who the producer is, I think I can finally make the connection: it's because of that "retro future" aesthetic *whatever you call it* also present in songs like Telepathy and Express 999 (which I both love) — and you mentioned Daft Punk! What's not to like?


Edited by Kookie., 07 May 2014 - 10:18 AM.

  • 0

B5F2qUz.gif

av: pandagirl, sig: taengledmess


dimaniwala dimaniwala
  • Donors
  • 356 posts
#9

Posted 07 July 2014 - 07:56 PM

Hi, I really enjoyed reading your reviews. Informative, thorough, and tons of analysis. I like how the review was objective but you still added a bit of your opinion, it allows you and your readers to discuss their own opinions about the songs.

 

I'm similar to most people in this thread in that I enjoyed Europa the most out of all the songs in the Mr.Mr. EP, can't explain why though. 


  • 0
<p style="text-align:center;"> <img src="http://fc05.devianta...gik-d48tqg8.gif" alt="man_vs_spider_by_cookiemagik-d48tqg8.gif"></p>
<p style="text-align:center;"> <span style="font-size:10px;">Cockroaches just never die do they?</span></p>
<p style="text-align:center;"><span style="font-size:10px;"> cr: Cookiemagik</span>


1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users